The Investment HabitThe boring parts, done for thirty years

Getting Started

Automatic Enrollment Chose A Default For You

Many workplace plans enroll employees automatically at a set rate into a default investment, which means a portfolio can exist before anyone has made a decision about it.

A professional working on a laptop at a round table with a card reader nearby.
Photograph by weCare Media via Pexels
General information. This is journalism, not personalised financial advice. Figures, rates and rules change and vary by country — check current terms before acting. How we work.

Many people begin investing without deciding to. Workplace plans commonly enroll employees automatically, at a rate and into a fund selected by the plan rather than by the participant.

The default was designed to overcome inaction

Participation in voluntary plans historically lagged because enrollment required an action, and the action was easy to postpone indefinitely.

Automatic enrollment reverses which outcome requires effort. Participation happens unless the employee opts out, and opting out requires the action that enrolling used to.

Federal law provides a framework encouraging these arrangements, including protections for plan sponsors who use qualifying default investments.

Two defaults are set, not one

The first is the contribution rate, a percentage of pay applied unless the participant selects something else. Plans may also increase it automatically over time under an escalation feature.

The second is the investment, typically a fund designed to serve as a default under the relevant rules, frequently a target-date fund keyed to an estimated retirement year.

Both defaults were chosen by the plan's fiduciaries for a population, not for an individual, and they remain in force until changed.

A target-date default carries an assumption

Target-date funds are assigned by birth year, which stands in for an expected retirement date. That assumption may or may not match a particular person's plans.

These funds hold a mix of assets that shifts over time according to a published schedule, so the allocation changes without any instruction from the participant.

Different fund families follow different schedules, including different treatments of the years after the target date, which is set out in each fund's documents.

Defaults persist because nothing prompts a review

Nothing in a plan requires periodic reconsideration. A rate and a fund chosen automatically at the start of employment can remain in place for many years.

Escalation features can also raise contributions gradually, which is visible in a paycheck but easy to attribute to other changes in withholding.

The absence of a prompt is the point of the design. It is what makes the arrangement effective and what makes reviewing it an action nobody is reminded to take.

Knowing what was chosen is the starting point

The plan's materials state the default rate, the escalation schedule if one exists and the identity of the default investment.

The account statement shows what is actually held, which is the only way to confirm whether a default is still in place or was changed at some point.

Whether any of it suits a particular situation depends on circumstances an article cannot see. The point here is narrower: a portfolio exists, and it was assembled by a rule.

Questions readers ask

Should I automate into a workplace scheme or my own account?

Where an employer matches contributions, that match is normally considered first because it is an immediate uplift, but scheme rules and tax treatment vary widely by country.

Does automating remove all judgement?

It removes the monthly judgement, which is the one made worst. Annual judgements about amount and structure remain, and those are the ones worth keeping.

Getting Startedautomationdefaultshabitcontributions
Alastair Nguyen
Editor, The Investment Habit

Alastair edits The Investment Habit and believes most investing content is entertainment sold as advice.

Also by Alastair Nguyen